Sunday, March 26, 2017
Women's Empowerment Brunch 2017
Facilitator Alana Lindsey of the Baobab Society recognized that ESF is on Haudenosaunee Territory, and then launched into questions.
Panelists noted "official" leadership duties as chairs and directors, but also mentors and in development of large classes, serving as counterpoints on committees, and as examples.
They shared times when their authority was not taken seriously. One observes that this is more noticeable at STEM institutions than in more comprehensive institutions, with a larger number of departments and more women faculty members. Another mentioned a male student explaining to her the purpose of her own class. Another that when they attempt to discuss such things with male coworkers that they imply that the issue is with her.
One mentioned that this occurs in classrooms, and wondered if its simply a new setting. Colleagues at other institutions assure her that no, there really is always a grandstander (usually male).
Female and male faculty are perceived very differently; there are studies that show that evaluations of male instructors will be rated 17% better without any other differences. Compounded by discrimation due to other immutable factors (young, being a person of color)--its hard to separate how much is because of female, country of origin, because grew up very rurally
Strategies:
MacPherson: Don't dismiss feelings; use something you love to move to the other side. [She] has artistic expression, voices [of authors, quotes]
Be willing to say, No, I can't do that.
Address assumptions head on: but can be perceived as cold, bitch. But if don't respond: pushover.
Dress so that you are comfortable and feel good about yourself (if you feel most confident in makeup, go for it!) and don't worry about other's opinions. (One notes that this is difficult--makeup takes a bit longer to get ready, easy care hairstyle or coloring requires more frequent appointments, and they do worry that others might perceive that this wasted time).
For People of Color, hair has been a political statement--it takes up physical space, and women are supposed to be as small and quiet as possible.
Take up space in attire as well--do I feel like dealing with comments today? If not, I choose to dress differently. If yes, go all out.
Question : importance of how women address other women, and how men address women. While the questioner wondered about this in the context of "slut shaming" (never cool), panelists dove into the issue of infantilizing women by referring to them as "girls." Consciously correct. Pronouns count!
Tips for Women of Color?
Work out what it is that you want to be. need to be happy with the progress you are making.
Don't let anyone suppress your flame. Know when its being tested, know when you need a break. Identify a survival kit with quotes to see you through to being whole. Find the MENTORING group for your field, or for women in your field.
Challenge yourself
I get interrupted a lot--what strategies can I employ? Be silent? Watch them run into a wall? Sometimes you need to interject: "Please let me finish" or "One more thing that I'd like to add before we move on"
Responses to anti-feminist comments, or you are "being too sensitive" or "taking it too seriously"?
(To be continued, in other forums!)
Baobab Society, Undergraduate Student Association-Student Inclusion, and ESF Women's Caucus
Friday, March 24, 2017
All Gender Bathrooms, effort to designate some others as
Thursday, March 23, 2017
Recent menstrual product initiative from USA
Thursday, January 26, 2017
Dams as a model for shared decision making and management.
Tuesday, December 13, 2016
What to say? A toolbox for confronting oppresive language
Each of us has multiple identities, with a race (or more than one), class, gender, sexuality, ethnicity (ethnicicities), language(s), religion(s), abilities/disabilities, etc. We need to get SMARTER about differences, about oppression, and about what it means to be an ally.
“Color blind” as not noticing differences is an odd construct. If someone said “I can’t tell a tree, from shrub, from a…I’m nature blind” we’d feel sorry for them. Not noticing things that are important to the other party—why isn’t that also the case?
How do we respond to differences? The general tendency is exclusion, mockery, scorn, marginalization. But, what if, rather than “that’s weird”…the response is "I wonder what life is like for that kid? Why do you wear that? I’ve never seen that food before. How do you celebrate that holiday?"
What about noticing how people are mis/treated because of their differences? Racism, sexism, homophobia, classism, religious oppression. Are there areas where you are good at noticing, but holes in others? (Hard to know what you don’t notice… a prior workshop: how many have experienced sexism? No hands raised. Not even someone yelling on the street “Hey, nice t!1s?” Well, yes, but that’s normal.) We can notice, or we can turn away.
“What would you do? Muslims in America”
She also notes that "No one EVER does this perfectly—the important thing is to keep practicing, and keep trying!" We look forward to more sessions to roleplay and to bring Dr. Sapon-Shevin back to work with even more of our colleagues!
This workshop was a collaboration of the ESF Women's Caucus, Committee on Inclusion, Diversity and Equity, and the Office of Student Diversity and Inclusion.
Tuesday, May 17, 2016
Empowering each other, and the girls coming behind us
Mid-semester, students Rhea Joseph, President of the Baobab Society, and Fatema Zubair and
Samantha McVey, Undergraduate Student Association's Co-Directors of Student Affairs and Diversity, approached us about collaborating on "a social mixer/brunch to promote women empowerment specifically in STEM related fields"-- something Rhea and Fatema had in in the backs of their minds for a while, but with graduation rapidly approaching, would need to do soon to participate themselves!! We brainstormed format and discussion points, they periodically reported back that they'd secured panelists, drafted questions and would like feedback on them, ordered food, were selling tickets, had sold out! And then April 10 was there--Baobab Society finalized the decorations, welcomed in a gender inclusive audience of 80 or so students, staff, faculty, who listened to these poised young women expertly facilitate the panel discussion, focusing on challenges in and out of the workplace, what helped, and what should the community really look at to truly assess the climate for women, so that students, faculty and staff succeed in an environment that promotes a sense of value, support and belonging, rather than persisting in spite of that environment.
Take home messages:
It's time to think about a different way of doing things, but some challenges remain.
You may not feel "like a full-fledged member" of a department, especially if you have different credentials than the others in your unit. But you can open doors (even a crack) for others to come through to be full members of the community and value the different opinions at the table.
The "family prices" can still seem as negative for women. You need supportive partners at home! At work, find people (or a group of people, like the Women's Caucus, or a virtual group, like the esfwomen listserv) to answer questions, bounce ideas, just be there and listen.
Club issue--feel like the only one. If you don't want to be part of an existing group, make your own! Even if its just a club of one.
Particular challenges that our panel faced: two started the tenure clock over when hired here (despite college's history of offering tenured title to others who had attained elsewhere), because (for one) that process for a woman of color at another institution was "just not up to the same standard." That made her more determined--"they won't be skeptical at the end!" She continued to feel marginalized--but cannot pin it on ethnicity, but on simply thinking differently. How do you get past that? Empower and talk to one another! Being intentional about working with women and supporting one another. Culturally, wait to speak until asked. Big challenge to learn to interrupt. Listen to those who say "You're strong." Bossy vs same behavior in men that is lauded. STEM fields considered very linear, but integration is much more valued now.
Sexually harassed by advisors? Currently there is more awareness of this, but women are still more at risk during travel.
How should we assess the climate for women? Its hard to measure a sense of belonging....do our curricula represent a plurality of ways of being? Thinking? How much do we integrate justice, ethics in science? How do we value all the different things folks bring? Do we listen? Do faculty learn? Retention and advancement in field! Are we persisting in spite of problems or succeeding within a strong support network? Keep moving forward!
....
Parallel to this event, Caucus staff met with individuals from Outreach, C-STEP, Diversity and Inclusion, SU's STEP program, and Girls Inc of YWCA to plan the 2016 Girls Summit, held at ESF and SU on May 7--a keynote by Dawn Benjamin, 8 workshops featuring a different STEM career (each girl attended 4), plus a college readiness panel of current college students facilitated by Mel Mennon, then of On Point for College. A record (I believe) 93! middle and high-school girls participated--putting "hard" (as in "concrete", not an assessment of difficulty) science and math into action, some with a social (aka "soft") science twist, to help them consider new fields for themselves, but also to see purpose in science and math, to stay interested in those subjects--as that interest is correlated with higher self esteem, and more options.
If the speed at which tickets were sold out to the first event is indicative of either a climate of support, or readiness to provide that, and a culture of inclusion, we are well on our way to be ready to support the Girls Summit participants, as students, and as community leaders, when those that choose to come here do so. Let's keep moving forward!
-he
Wednesday, April 13, 2016
Gwen Kay Discusses An Alternative View of Women’s Science Education
Dr.
Gwen Kay, Professor and Graduate Program Director of the History Department,
and Director of the Honors Program at SUNY Oswego, presented her research
titled Not Just Stitchin’ &
Stirrin’—An Alternative View of Women’s Science Education at ESF on
Wednesday, April 13, 2016 as part of SUNY ESF’s Women in Scientific and
Environmental Professions Spring Speaker Series. The ESF Women’s Caucus and the Environmental
Scholars program jointly sponsored the presentation.As part of their course requirements, students in FOR797 share responsibility for reporting on the WiSE Professions speaker series. The preceding was prepared by Holly Granat, Department of Forest and Natural Resources Management, M.S./M.P.A. Candidate
Wednesday, March 9, 2016
Rochester Roots: Excellence in Community Sustainability Education
By
incorporating hands-on gardening experiences, students are able to learn the
value of gardening and food preparation which empowers youth, family, and
community. These community gardens - repurpose otherwise abandoned land which
simultaneously approves aesthetics. In addition, the produce can be sold at
market or used in product development, serving additional lessons in marketing
and sales.Students in FOR797 Env Career Strategies for Women share responsibilty for reporting on the WiSE Professions Speaker Series. The preceding was prepared by Kelley Corbine, Nicolette Fruehan, Devin Hansen and Joel Ramtahal, all graduate students in the Department of Forest and Natural Resources Management.
Monday, March 7, 2016
Girls' Summit introduces ESF careers to community teens
CNY Girls Summit STEAM Career Conference for area middle and high schoolers returned to ESF on May 7.
Of the eight workshops offered during the
program, half had very close ESF ties. Dr. Biljana Bujanovic’s team helped
participants make paper, tested strength of commercial paper, and led facility
tours. Dr. Whitney Lash Marshall
facilitated a systems thinking exercise, while Ms. Linda McGuigan guided
participants through extracting DNA from strawberries and discussed the
Chestnut project. Alumna Ms. Kritika
Thapa, now with EA Engineering, challenged groups through a water filtration
exercise. In addition, first year student Jet’aime “Jet”
Lewis joined a College Preparation Panel
with moderator Mel Menon, of On Point for College, and students from
Upstate Medical University, SU, OCC, and LeMoyne College.
Post-workshop
surveys of the 90+ participants indicated that participants were indeed introduced to new
careers and left with a greater interest in science and math than when they
arrived. Paper making and DNA extraction
were clear favorites of the participants, with water filtration not far behind.
Tuesday, January 12, 2016
SUNY aims to increase diversity
Do these efforts go far enough? The CDO's duties were in addition to her existing ones. While there are many parallels, that's still a lot to add on to one person's plate! And that office works almost exclusively with students. We are so proud of the ESF student organizations that called for greater efforts toward a culturally inclusive campus, and that facilitated open forums to brainstorm questions and directions.
And this week, SUNY Chancellor Nancy Zimper included this passage in the State of the University Address--we hope, really truly to see our CDO position grow with those in the SUNY network to help faculty and staff communicate across campuses, cultures, learning styles, genders.



